OK, for those of you who are unfamiliar with the back story for this post the original post can be found here.
The date went fantastic! What I initially thought was going to be a 30 minute talk, ended up being a two and a half hour talk over Chick-fil-A. Obviously, according the original post, I was terrified, but the fact that we were born on the same day, in the same hour, in the same hospital, next door to each other was a major ice-breaker. I was really apprehensive about the whole deal, but we discovered that we have so much in common that we wouldn't have known otherwise. On the plus side, she initiated that we should get together during the summer and after college finals are finished.
THANKS REDDIT FOR ALL THE KIND AND SUPPORTIVE ADVICE!!!!
It's good knowing that there's another community of support and advice willing to there for support**
ANOTHER NOTE: I showed my college roommate her picture, just to make sure that she wasn't the same girl that one of our mutual friends was semi-dating. He was an asshole about it and mentioned how the other girl was so much hotter, BUT Beth turned out to be gorgeous and there was a genuine connection between us. However, to my roommate's credit, he had no idea that I was going out with her.... At the time, she was just someone that I was meeting...
TL;DR I had a fantastic time on the date, and felt a genuine connection with a girl since my last awful break-up. What was supposed to be a 30 minute meet-up was a 2.5 hour long conversation over lunch. She initiated that we should get together during the summer. May have found my other half!